M&A Mooney & Associates M&A Mooney & Associates
  • Personal Injury
    • Vehicle Accidents
      • Automobile
      • Motorcycle
      • Tractor Trailer
      • Pedestrian
      • Bicycle
      • Recreational Vehicle Accidents
      • Boating Accidents
    • Workplace Injuries
      • Workers’ Compensation
      • Federal Government Worker’s Compensation
    • Disability
      • Social Security Disability
      • Long-Term Disability
    • Medical Injuries
      • Birth Injuries
      • Defective Medical Devices
      • Defective Drugs
    • General Personal Injuries
      • Dog Bites & Animal Attacks
      • Slips & Falls
      • Product Liability
      • Catastrophic Injury & Wrongful Death
  • Criminal Defense
    • DUI/DWI
    • White Collar & Federal Crimes
    • Drug Crimes
    • Parole & Probation
    • Theft & Property Crimes
    • Pardons & Expungements
    • Sexual Offenses
    • Traffic Violations
    • Violent & Serious Crimes
  • Family & Immigration
    • Family Law
      • Divorce
      • Custody
      • Adoption
      • Pre & Post Nuptials
    • Immigration Law
      • Citizenship & Naturalization
      • Visas
      • Asylum
  • Business & Real Estate
    • Business & Commercial Law
      • Business Formation
      • Collection & Litigation
      • Contracts
      • Mergers & Acquistions
      • Business Tax Law
      • Intellectual Property
      • Unemployment Compensation
    • Real Estate Law
      • Settlements & Title Insurance
      • Refinancing
      • Zoning Appeals & Litigation
      • Real Estate Foreclosures
      • Oil & Gas Rights
  • Bankruptcy
    • Business Bankruptcy
      • Chapter 7 Business Bankruptcy
      • Chapter 11
      • Chapter 12
    • Personal Bankruptcy
      • Chapter 7 Personal Bankruptcy
      • Chapter 13
      • Foreclosures
  • Estate Law
    • Wills & Estate Planning
    • Estate Administration & Probate
    • Long Term Care
    • Nursing Homes
    • Trusts & Asset Protection
    • Medicaid Planning
    • Veterans Benefits
Schedule a Consultation 717-200-HELP Se habla español (4357)
Read Our Blog
Mooney gets tampering charges dropped against Hanover Constable
by Mark Buterbaugh Read Now
Mooney & Associates announces a Frederick, Maryland office location
by Mark Buterbaugh Read Now
What is a real estate closing?
by George Swartz Read Now
More Areas of Practice
    • Locations
      • Carlisle
      • Chambersburg
      • Duncannon
      • Frederick
      • Gettysburg
      • Greencastle
      • Halifax
      • Hanover
      • Harrisburg
      • Lancaster
      • Lebanon
      • Mercersburg
      • New Oxford
      • Shippensburg
      • Stewartstown
      • Westminster
      • York
    • Attorneys
      • John J. Mooney III
      • George W. Swartz II
      • Jason Imler
      • Mark A. Buterbaugh
      • S. Wade Parker
      • Shawn M. Stottlemyer
      • Clayton A. Lingg
      • H. Corky Goldstein
      • Tyann L. Miller
      • Jessica E. Weaver
      • James P. Welch
      • Andrew S. Withers
      • Paul B. Royer
      • Andrew S. Ziegler
    • About Mooney & Associates
      • Overview
      • Results
      • Fees & How We Work
      • Videos & Resources
      • Forms
      • Careers
      • Attorney Referrals
    • Contact Us 717-200-HELP Se habla español (4357)
      Make Payment
      Schedule a consultation?

      So we don’t waste your time and get right to your questions, please complete the Welcome Form and bring it along to our meeting. Thank You!

      Welcome Form
    Home | Blog | Dog Bite on Break is within Course and Scope of Employment

    Dog Bite on Break is within Course and Scope of Employment

    11/25/2014 by Mark Buterbaugh
    How are dog bite injuries at work covered?

    One of the critical elements of proving a Claim Petition in Pennsylvania Workers Compensation is whether the injury occurred in the course and scope of  employment. The course and scope element has been heavily litigated over the years and the rules are a bit clearer today. However, at times, course and scope issues still arise.

    Recently the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court addressed the course and scope issue on a dog bite incident that occurred at work. The facts are quite simple. In this case, a part-time employee at a restaurant was injured when he was bitten by a co-worker’s dog. The employers contended that the incident occurred while the employee was on break and occurred off the business property in a public alley. Additionally, the Defendant averred that the employee was warned that the dog had a tendency to snap. On the other hand, the employee asserted that the employer had two approved smoke breaks, that the employer actually provided an ashtray tower at the location of the incident, and that no positive work order was instructed to not take the break and pet the dog.

    The Court upheld the WCJ decision that the course and scope element was met. The Court’s opinion stated,

    Thus, in finding that Claimant was injured in the course and scope of his employment, the WCJ considered the events surrounding the incident and the location where the injury occurred.

    The employer also contended that the employees actions were more than a mere, temporary departure from work duties. Essentially, the employer contended that the act of petting the dog was the act that exceeded more than temporary departure from work activities. The Court rejected that argument.

    This departure from Claimant’s work is not comparable to the departure in Trigon Holdings. Claimant did not make a pronounced departure from his work; 12 rather, he was on a break expressly permitted by Employer in an area designated by Employer as the break area. In addition, Claimant did not feel the need to inform his co-workers that he would be departing from his normal duties as a line cook. Claimant testified that at some point during the smoke break all of the employees on duty that night were outside with him. (2010 FOF ¶ 6; Hr’g Tr. at 8, R.R. at 79a.) Therefore, the WCJ did not err in finding that Claimant’s act of petting the dog was a temporary departure from his work duties. 

    Finally, the Court rejected the notion that the employee was willful because he was warned that the dog was aggressive.

    Here, before petting the dog, Claimant held out his hand to determine whether the dog would be receptive to him. (Hr’g Tr. at 7, R.R. at 78a.) After determining that the dog would be receptive, Claimant got down on his knee and the dog began to lick his face. (Hr’g Tr. at 7, R.R. at 78a.) Claimant also testified
    that he did not do anything to antagonize the dog into biting him. (Hr’g Tr. at 10, R.R. at 81a.) Therefore, Claimant’s act of petting the dog was not “premeditated,deliberate, extreme, and inherently of a high-risk nature,” Penn State University,
    15 A.3d at 954, so as to remove him from his course of employment.

    The Court wrapped up its affirming opinion by recognizing prior case law that confirmed that smoking during intervals, smoke breaks, do not interfere with work duties and are therefore not deviations from the course and scope of employment.

    Share This Article:
    Prev Article Next Article
    Back to All Blog Articles

    Related Articles

    Mooney & Associates Law Firm Logo

    Mooney gets tampering charges dropped against Hanover Constable

    04/18/2018 by Mark Buterbaugh
    Read More
    Mooney & Associates Law Firm Logo

    Mooney & Associates announces a Frederick, Maryland office location

    04/10/2018 by Mark Buterbaugh
    Read More
    Mooney & Associates Law Firm Logo

    What is a real estate closing?

    04/09/2018 by George Swartz
    Read More

    The Most Trusted Lawyers

    When you partner with the attorneys of Mooney & Associates, you can trust two things: our knowledge and experience in every field of law, and that when you call us, a lawyer will answer your questions and concerns promptly. We have a long history of negotiating maximum settlements and successfully fighting for our clients in the courtroom.

    Meet Our Attorneys Law Office Locations

    footer-mark-buterbaugh
    When I needed to negotiate about my land, I knew I could Count on Mooney.

    Areas of Practice

    • Personal Injury
      • Vehicle Accidents
        • Automobile
        • Motorcycle
        • Tractor Trailer
        • Pedestrian
        • Bicycle
        • Recreational Vehicle Accidents
        • Boating Accidents
      • Workplace Injuries
        • Workers’ Compensation
        • Federal Government Worker’s Compensation
      • Disability
        • Social Security Disability
        • Long-Term Disability
      • Medical Injuries
        • Birth Injuries
        • Defective Medical Devices
        • Defective Drugs
      • General Personal Injuries
        • Dog Bites & Animal Attacks
        • Slips & Falls
        • Product Liability
        • Catastrophic Injury & Wrongful Death
    • Criminal Defense
      • DUI/DWI
      • White Collar & Federal Crimes
      • Drug Crimes
      • Parole & Probation
      • Theft & Property Crimes
      • Pardons & Expungements
      • Sexual Offenses
      • Traffic Violations
      • Violent & Serious Crimes
    • Family & Immigration
      • Family Law
        • Divorce
        • Custody
        • Adoption
        • Pre & Post Nuptials
      • Immigration Law
        • Citizenship & Naturalization
        • Visas
        • Asylum
    • Business & Real Estate
      • Business & Commercial Law
        • Business Formation
        • Collection & Litigation
        • Contracts
        • Mergers & Acquistions
        • Business Tax Law
        • Intellectual Property
        • Unemployment Compensation
      • Real Estate Law
        • Settlements & Title Insurance
        • Refinancing
        • Zoning Appeals & Litigation
        • Real Estate Foreclosures
        • Oil & Gas Rights
    • Bankruptcy
      • Business Bankruptcy
        • Chapter 7 Business Bankruptcy
        • Chapter 11
        • Chapter 12
      • Personal Bankruptcy
        • Chapter 7 Personal Bankruptcy
        • Chapter 13
        • Foreclosures
    • Estate Law
      • Wills & Estate Planning
      • Estate Administration & Probate
      • Long Term Care
      • Nursing Homes
      • Trusts & Asset Protection
      • Medicaid Planning
      • Veterans Benefits
    • About Us
      • Overview
      • Results
      • Fees & How We Work
      • Videos & Resources
      • Forms
      • Careers
      • Attorney Referrals
    • Read Our Blog
    • Locations
    • Attorneys
    • Contact Us 717-200-HELPSe habla español(4357)
    • Make Payment
    © 2018 Mooney & Associates. Central PA Attorneys at Law. All rights reserved.
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy
    • Sitemap